Tuesday, 31 March 2020

Pandemic Paternity Leave






My professional diary has, between different dates this year, had 'Speak to Max' noted on it. This was an instruction to my clerks to speak to me before booking in trials as I was intending to resume paternity leave to enable my wife to return to work before the baby had his first birthday.

Needless to say these dates were pencilled in just waiting to be rubbed out by a case coming along that I just couldn't refuse. Initially the plan had been for a three month period, when last we had spoken about this it had become a month as an adjunct to the summer holidays.

I know that it was never the dying regret of any barrister that they had not taken on more cases. Conversely if you miss those early days, months and years you miss them forever. And yet how much of a chasm lies there between awareness and action.

Almost all barristers fear that if they step off the treadmill they will somehow never get back on it or find that their place on it has been usurped by someone keener, more focused on the job, less distracted by family. No barrister ever imagined that the treadmill would suddenly one day stop turning.

Exactly a week ago I was on Day 34 of a jury trial with a judge determined to shepherd the case to a result while the gathering storm clouds swirled around us. To the eternal credit of that jury they shared his determination but, inevitably, events overtook us all and the plug was pulled and, immediately, I was unemployed.

Except as a father to a 3 year old and a baby I was anything but. Absurdly, despite my empty diary, I could have claimed key worker status to keep the 3 year old in nursery but with no income that would have been a crazy expense far from the spirit of the exception.

So I am now a house husband and a stay at home dad rapidly discovering what I had long suspected, namely that no fraud, however complex or torturous, can compare with the difficulty of pacifying two screaming children at the same time.

I have been spoken to fairly shortly and sharply by judges in my time but even the most irascible judge is not as unreasonable as an actual howling toddler. The Coronavirus is doing an almost unimaginable amount of harm in the world and leaving tragedy in its wake but for me, and I'm sure many fathers like me, it is forcing an adjustment to our roles in the workplace and in our families.

For the time being I really am a father first and for all that I have lost professionally I know that these terrible circumstances have given me a gift not to be squandered. And, if I really miss the day job, I'm sure nobody will mind if I wear my wig pushing the pram around the park.

Tuesday, 4 February 2020

Stuck fast - Going nowhere fast


Dawdling is the schoolboys' luxury. Think about when you last genuinely had a saunter, feeling under no pressure to be anywhere at any particular time. Small children feel this way on almost any walk unless they're vouchsafed ice cream or chocolate cake at its end. If you're weekending in the sticks or on holiday moving at a child's pace can be wonderfully restorative and an important reminder to notice the world with a child's noticing. If you're trying to get literally anywhere in London it is absolutely infuriating.

All parents will be familiar with the sit-down protest. As all good parents know this is the moment to get on a level with your child, without rancour or ill will, and just be with them until the inclination to rise up and continue moves on them. Yeah, just try doing that in the middle of Park Lane...

I have no compunction about enacting an executive override of my 3 year old's mobile autonomy and carrying him bodily but at 20 kgs that makes him a very irregularly shaped dumb bell and a very noisy one to boot.

There is another way. It requires excellent peripheral vision, some basic spying skills and a tolerance for a very small amount of jeopardy. The sit down protest is a battle of wills. Pleading: pointless. Reasoning: ridiculous. Bribing: basic. Instead the path to success lies, as always, in not caring. Now, because it's your kid, you can't literally not care (that is bad) so you have to affect indifference.

Just walk away - Speed, distance and purpose are important here. If you go too slowly your child won't notice, if you go too far they might run into traffic (this is bad) or, implausibly, but it's every parent's bogeyman fear, get snatched. If you hesitate they know you're faking and your heart's not in it.

On the other hand if you do this properly, and use your peripheral vision, you can stride purposefully and watch your child watching you. Eventually they will realise you're in earnest and come running. Some particularly stubborn children may have not got to their feet before you reach your self-imposed safe distance limit (hint: a kilometre is too far). If this happens you deploy your KGB training. Do NOT turn around. You may as well wave a white flag. Rather use the wing mirror of a parked car to watch your child. Your child won't have had any driving lessons so won't know anything about wing mirrors. Eventually your child will come to you. 

The important thing is to make movement their decision. The illusion of choice is child's play.

Sunday, 19 January 2020

Consolation Prize

Incompetence is the stock in trade of parenting blogs and this is never truer when written by dads. But this is as tiresome a cliche as 'Mum's gone to Iceland'. The fact is that a lot of parenting is not that hard and even dads can do it. They might not do it to mums' satisfaction but that does not mean they can't do it.

Changing nappies - easy. Shovelling food in their mouth - walk in the park. Putting their clothes on - child's play. Getting them in the child seat - ok, that one's a nightmare but it's an equal opportunities nightmare.

Turning off the tears, however...

That is my blind spot, my Achilles' heel, my Waterloo. I remain convinced that there is some kind of whispered incantation that baby girls learn at their mothers' elbow that enables them to hush a baby with a moment's talk. Indeed I wish it were so because if that is not the case then my abject failure to quell my baby's sobs really is on me alone.

Lest you think I exaggerate I can see {call the police?} thought processing in the eyes of strangers in the street as I walk by with my wildly protesting offspring. My blessed wife with increasing levels of exasperation tries to tutor me. 'Just sing him a song' - basic advice for a basic dad but as useful to me as asking me to recite Horace from memory while running across No Man's Land towards a very active machine gun nest.

The main issue I have with soothing a howling baby is that I need someone to soothe me before I can minister to the demented banshee. Rather like that instruction on planes to put the oxygen mask on your own face before your child's where is the person who will apply the handbrake to my berserking brain?

Ordinarily a discomforting noise is supposed to set one's teeth on edge in my case it makes me madly itchy which renders bouncing the bawler all the more perilous as I frantically claw at my inner elbow. I used to think I was a pretty imperturbable chap. I used to think a lot of foolish things.

Anyway, no great insights here, just a desperate plea for the magic words. Pretty please.

Monday, 18 November 2019

Buy This Book!




You would not learn to drive by reading a manual written by someone who has never driven and yet, remarkably, you can buy parenting books written by the childfree/childless. I have written before about my general disregard and distrust of parenting by the book/s but that was because the right book had not yet been written. Calling your book 'The Book You Wish Your Parents Had Read' certainly suggests no lack of confidence on the author's part but the truth is we all long for advice from those quietly confident in its soundness.

That is not to suggest for one second that Philippa Perry, its author, claims absolute knowledge about the best way to parent. She does however take real pains to set out why some of the conclusions she draws are well founded by her researches and, most particularly, by her own experiences of parenting. She is quick to illustrate reflections upon her own childhood experiences in consciously shaping her own intentions for parenthood.

A remarkable number of people seem not to question their own childhood experiences or weigh up what was successful or less successful about their parents' parenting. True it is that there are a lucky few whose early years were characterised by clear boundaries within which needs both basic and complex were attended to and there was the fullest possible realisation of physical, emotional, intellectual and spiritual development but was that genuinely your experience? Even if it was it's impossible that came about by pure chance.

A lot of parenting books insist upon a clear right way/wrong way duality with wholly implausible case histories where the author's edicts are followed to a T and overnight a howling banshee becomes a model of docility. There is often a distinct absence of kindness and gentleness in the imparting of advice and that is where Perry excels. In her words it's never too late to repair the ruptures. And ruptures there will always be despite and sometimes because of our best intentions.

Another thing that Perry gives a lot of thought to is the vocabulary of parenting. She decries the description of children as naughty or bad but instead, rightly, suggests a focus on the causes of the behaviour being exhibited. Characterising, as she does, 'bad' behaviour as inconvenient may seem euphemistic or mealy-mouthed but the reality is that the worst toddler meltdowns are the worst because they happen in the most inconvenient ways at the most inconvenient times.

The hardest truth of parenting to absorb and process is its inconvenience but resistance to this truth does perhaps more harm to children than anything else. At the start of parenting it comes as a shock that you have to sublimate your desires (convenience) to meet your child's needs every single time. A baby's cries are a very effective way of ensuring that the immediacy of that requirement should not be overlooked. Although a baby can be 'trained' to an emotional awareness that decibels don't work. That uncomfortably is what 'sleep training' depends upon. Deliberately rendering impotent your child's only means of communication might be convenient but it's also very uncomfortable.

Children have needs. They are never needy. If children's needs are neglected that neglect often manifests in adulthood as neediness. When a parent prioritises their convenience over their child's needs they simply defer a debt that will have to be paid at a most inconvenient time in a most inconvenient way. The good news is that it is never too late to settle the account.

Sunday, 3 November 2019

Hypocrite lecteur, — mon semblable, — mon frère!






I am bad at maths. Numbers are no problem but letters send me loopy. Even well into adolescence I would be reduced to tears at my incompetence at something that came effortlessly to my peers. Everybody can identify with that consuming anguish that engulfs the body when you just don't get it, even when the teacher patiently explains for the thousandth time. So it is with baby pacification, gummy smiles give way to howling hysteria the instant the baby passes from my wife's arms to mine (and the baby doesn't enjoy it either).

Walk him around. Sing him a song. Don't hold him like that. Don't bounce him on your knee. Even an idiot could follow those simple instructions. Plainly I have yet to graduate idiot school. There is a vicious circle. When the mother does all the mothering what right minded baby wants an ersatz paternal substitute. But if the dad doesn't do the primary care giving he will never be baby's first choice. And if the baby is benefiting from breast is best that top spot on the podium is as inaccessible as Mount Olympus.

Another Saturday another long read in the Guardian about patriarchy's enduring stranglehold and why there is nothing natural about male supremacy in the world. A concomitant conclusion is that there is nothing pre-ordained about maternal primacy in the home. And yet. 3 years into being a dad and still basically as clueless  as when I started; I have a strange hankering to meet and learn from single dads. And I don't mean ones that have outsourced to a nanny or their mother but the ones that are genuinely doing it on their own.

I don't know any fathers who are parenting without the benefit of female assistance/input/instruction and I assume they are few and far between. They are certainly not a common cultural trope. Likewise, how often do you read mothers writing about how their partners take the lead and the load when it comes to child rearing and domestic labour? Almost never.

There was a cartoon that did the rounds a couple of years back about unequal bearing of emotional labour by women and the effort involved in giving instruction to useless men. I could scarcely get to the end so excoriatingly close to the bone did it cut. I didn't want to be that guy, I don't want to be that guy and yet, so often, I am that guy.

It's a cliche but parenting is about teamwork and communication. But an important codicil to this excellent advice is that all teams have a captain. Someone has to be in charge. And captaincy carries its burdens but also its privileges. When two parents equally decline to take responsibility there is not a happy outcome for the children. However the same is also true when both parents vie for the task of laying down the ground rules. Perhaps the secret is familial government by tribunes but I've rarely seen that in action.

My wife recently laid the charge of hypocrisy against me to which my plea is unequivocally guilty. If you want to see a dad stepping up to the plate and putting in his shift don't read a blog by a man about parenting; any proper dad has no time for navel gazing like that. And just as fine words butter no parsnips they wipe no bottoms, noses or work surfaces either.

I know that I am hardly alone in wanting to be a better parent and a better father but sometimes I feel as Nancy Astor must have when she first took her seat in a place built by men for men. I have been to enough mother and baby activities to know that other than the occasional token bloke they are for mothers and babies. On a recent extraordinary outing to Water Babies with my toddler it was only dads that turned up. The swimming teacher could not overcome her cognitive dissonance and kept on addressing us as 'Mums'.

I am crying out for writing by dads for dads. Until then I prostrate myself before my wife as yet again the co-pilot has put the parenting plane into a nosedive.

Sunday, 27 October 2019

Father's Faith



Recently I rushed to Rome for 24 hours in order to attend the canonisation of John Henry Newman at the Vatican. Unless you are a Catholic or a particularly keen Anglican you may have not heard of him but he was a Church of England priest who converted to Catholicism in 1845 and later became a Cardinal. He is also the reason why my family is Catholic because one of my ancestors was his contemporary and was persuaded by his writings, teachings and personality to follow him to Rome.

How much screen time, breast or bottle, nursery or child minder - these are questions all modern parents grapple with. Should we give our child religion? Not so much. In observant families religious education/indoctrination obviously remains a foregone conclusion. In wholly secularised families the question probably does not even arise.

That leaves the 'maybes' and I am intrigued and identify with the 'maybes'. I am confirmed Catholic but find the notion of godhead worrying itself about human beings' sex lives absolutely absurd. Furthermore I do not subscribe to a bad apple analysis of clerical sexual abuse but instead see it as a poisoning of the  entire holy well. Even one priest making a mockery of Jesus' command to suffer the little children deals a mortal blow to the moral authority of the church. When it transpires that rather than rooting out this cancer the church has, it would appear, connived to hide these criminals under its cassock it is little wonder that many parents hesitate before entrusting their children to the clergy.

All of that before one even begins to address the powerful ambivalence triggered by embracing patriarchy's granddaddy. And yet I was married in church, my first child baptised and my second soon to be. The Catholic Church welcomes babies with open arms but try joining as an adult and you'll find the Royal Marines selection process is less testing.

Suffice to say if my childhood experiences of churchgoing had been marred by even the slightest wrongdoing I certainly would not be writing this. Instead I was an enthusiastic acolyte at Farm Street which, as you can see, is full of light and colour.




Its priests are Jesuits and its choir is exceptional. I derive comfort from the liturgy, from ritual and sacred music can be absolutely transcending. Obviously it is easy to balk at the so muchness of Catholicism, the literal gilding of the lily. Perhaps the Quakers have it right in their stillness and simplicity. But the richness and splendour is, for me, a pure manifestation of the human desire to adore and to revere.

I know that the religious hardly have a monopoly on spiritual transportation and many derive a sense of the numinous at mountain tops or in great forests and, no doubt, some exceptional types may feel it even in the midst of the throng on Oxford Street. But when religion is not war, not hypocrisy, not interference in people's lives and their bodily autonomy it has the capacity to cater to some very fundamental but also some very evolved human needs.

But that's a lot of buts and perhaps the best kind of parenting permits children to make their own voyages of discovery towards or away from faith and religion. It's to my wholly secular wife's credit that she has sanctioned my introducing our children to what I have known and rejoiced in but also been disappointed by.

Faith, or its absence, is obviously an intensely personal thing but it's a family thing too.


Friday, 20 September 2019

You, me, and baby make 3, add one more & now we're 4


What do you give that takes away? Answer - a sister or, in our case, a brother. If a sibling is the greatest gift you can give your child you at the same time deprive them of your undivided attention. This is, of course, a good thing, although notoriously few first-borns feel that way when their 100% suddenly goes half price.

As an elder sibling it is fair to say I harboured some quiet anxieties as to how Hardy 1 might take to the arrival of Hardy 2 and although I have no conscious memory of the arrival of my sister there will always be an atavistic awareness that while Katherine may have been great for my parents she was a massive gatecrasher at the Max party.

So it was that the elder was kept on a tight leash for the introduction with, (oldest trick in the book), a very large new toy, ('a gift from baby'), on hand to sweeten the bitter pill. Turns out I had nothing to worry about. His ecstatic cries of delight even sounded as though they might be genuine and if there was a modicum of disappointment that we had failed to deliver the clearly requested big sister he did a consummate job of hiding it.

And here we are 7 weeks down the track and he seems just as pleased that he's no longer flying solo. Indeed he is ever solicitous of the baby's well-being and swift to shower him in kisses which never once threaten suddenly a smothering. I suppose touching 3 he is not yet conscious of any diminution of resources although it's only a matter of time before he comes to learn that the Bank of Mum & Dad has a new customer.

If there is one mild criticism to make it is that on the subject of shrieking he has revealed himself to be a rank hypocrite. It turns out that toddlers detest screaming baby blue murder as much as the rest of us. Yet it does not occur to him, strapped in the back of the car, making increasingly hysterical demands of his baby brother that he stop crying that just perhaps the pot is calling the kettle black.

But this is a trifle and at the moment all bodes well for the Hardy Boys.